Thursday, March 28, 2024 |
Aditi Rao Hydari misses ‘Heeramandi’ event after weddingBigg Boss winner Munawar Faruqui among 14 detained in Mumbai raidMrunal Thakur follows ‘grandma diet,’ believes in not skipping mealsSelena Gomez shares makeup-free selfies on InstagramDiljit collaborates with Saweetie for ‘Khutti’ Song, says ‘she just landed in Punjab’Malaika Arora, Arjun Kapoor, Richa, Ali Fazal, Farah, and more at KJo’s BashJamie Lever is ‘honoured’ to represent her heritage with Telugu debut filmJanhvi and Aditya Roy Kapur shine on the ramp for Kalki at Lakme Fashion Week x FDCII am fond of Kate Moss, says Diana Penty, about her fashion iconKriti Kharbanda, Pulkit Samrat share pictures from dreamy wedding

Culture vs court: What reigns supreme?

Posted January 9th, 2019, 10:43 AM IST

Culture vs court: What reigns supreme?

The recent entry of two women into Sabarimala temple — Kanakadurga and Bindu has only added fuel to the ongoing protests by pro-Hindu groups and activists against allowing women to enter the shrine.

While failure to implement the Supreme Court ruling (allowing women of all ages to enter) is deemed Contempt of Court, recent times have seen a slew of instances where the prevailing cultural and religious practices have confronted the court ruling. From Sabarimala, to Jallikattu and cockfights to a ban of crackers during festivals (read Diwali), blatant violations of Supreme Court orders by various sections of society have sparked a debate. Is the spread of the virus of ‘contempt of court’ setting a dangerous precedent for the future?





jpg

Gopalakrishna Tamada, former justice, High Court of Andhra Pradesh, calls this development, ‘unfortunate’. “The concerned authorities should be held responsible for this violation of law. Either the one who has filed the petition should re-file the petition, or the Courts should take up the case as suo moto and initiate action. Unfortunately neither of the two is happening,” he laments.

Command vs Tradition
While the court also had intervened when it came to practices like Jallikattu, cock fights and fireworks during recent Diwali, the verdict only looked like ‘mocking enforcement’ with the enforcers pleading helplessness against the general will. During Sankranti festival, cockfights and Jallikattu continue. While festive practices are carried with no intent to cause harm, can a command overrule cultural traditions? And to what extent should the law interfere in cultural issues? These are the questions that are stoking public debate today. Sociologist Shiv Vishwanath thinks that the courts should give time to implement the ruling. “The court should always give enough time to implement the decision before the issue turns out to be a complex one. When society is divided, it takes time to find a consensus. So cultural issues, if not dealt with carefully, will eventually turn into a political one,” he asserts.

Empowering people — The only way forward
In the midst of such violent protests, how can things be resolved peacefully? Chandra Kumar, former justice, High Court of Andhra Pradesh, believes that empowering people is the only way forward “Widow marriages were banned long back, but it took several years to bring a change in the mindset of society to accept it,” he points out, adding, “Some of Supreme Court’s decisions have been ahead of times. Unfortunately the society hasn’t grown up to such a level to embrace such a cultural transformation overnight. I think courts should be sensitive to culture. But when things are chaotic like this, the people should be empowered and educated on the emerging cultural changes to put things to rest,” says Chandra Kumar.

Women’s equality a Constitutional right
Kavita Krishnan, Secretary, All India Progressive Women’s Association, says that the Sabarimala issue is not about religious sentiment, but about the constitutional rights of human beings. “The Sabarimala issue is like protesting against equality. The very thought that women would break the sanctity of God is in itself fundamentally wrong and offensive to women. It is against the constitutional rights of the women,” she explains, adding, “So it is more of a debate between Constitution vs the flawed court ruling by the Kerala High court which in 1991 imposed a ban on women entering the temple.”

Sharing

Photos
Latest

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Warning

Message: file_get_contents(): http:// wrapper is disabled in the server configuration by allow_url_fopen=0

Filename: views/newsdetails.php

Line Number: 29

Backtrace:

File: /home5/am2pm/public_html/application/views/newsdetails.php
Line: 29
Function: file_get_contents

File: /home5/am2pm/public_html/application/controllers/News.php
Line: 135
Function: view

File: /home5/am2pm/public_html/application/controllers/News.php
Line: 83
Function: newsdetails

File: /home5/am2pm/public_html/index.php
Line: 315
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Warning

Message: file_get_contents(http://www.indiaaffiliates.in/ads.php?size=300X250): failed to open stream: no suitable wrapper could be found

Filename: views/newsdetails.php

Line Number: 29

Backtrace:

File: /home5/am2pm/public_html/application/views/newsdetails.php
Line: 29
Function: file_get_contents

File: /home5/am2pm/public_html/application/controllers/News.php
Line: 135
Function: view

File: /home5/am2pm/public_html/application/controllers/News.php
Line: 83
Function: newsdetails

File: /home5/am2pm/public_html/index.php
Line: 315
Function: require_once

Opinion Poll
shambo shankara movie
Hit
Average
flop
Advertisement
advertisement
Videos