Social distancing seems alien to Indians
Posted March 31st, 2020, 10:04 AM IST

The term “social distance” doesn’t seem to be working. Across the nation, law enforcement agencies are struggling to convince people to maintain even a foot’s distance between each other.
Arm-chair psychologists believe this is because Indians have no concept of “personal space”. Real psychologists, while not dismissing the idea altogether, said the subject was more complicated than that.
Dr Pragya Rashmi, a consultant psychologist from the city, said the concept of “body buffer zone” in psychology the physical distance a person prefers to maintain from another varies between cultures.
“Physical proximity is a part of our culture. We easily touch other people through hugs and whatnot,” she said. Dr Rashmi noted that the idea of personal space differs even between those who live in urban spaces and those who live in rural, open spaces.
Clinical psychologist Aarthi Selvan, who runs a clinic in Begumpet, said the current behaviour of people at market yards and supermarkets can be explained in another way as well.
“During times like these, there is a component of fear and anxiety around the availability of resources. They aren’t sure if essential goods will be available,” she said. This nervousness could lead people to forget the risks of being in a crowd or not maintaining a distance from others. “There isn’t a lot of information being given to the general public. Their anxiety is understandable,” she said.
“In any case, the idea of social distancing is a privilege in our country. Most people can’t afford to live in a place where they have any real personal space,” she added.
Psychologists as well as many Dalit and Adivasi activists have noted that the term “social distancing” might not be the most ideal one to use in India.
Activists have noted that the term has caste undertones, and could allude to untouchability that was practised against certain communities in the country. Some have suggested it be replaced by “physical distancing”.
Dr Rashmi said, “The term ‘social distancing’ doesn’t clearly convey its purpose. People still don’t know why they should maintain a distance from others.” She suggested the use of “safe distance” instead.
Ms Selvan too said the word “social” was leading to the message being lost in transmission. “Indeed, ‘safe distance’ might work. It is less likely to elicit a threat response from people. It could also elicit a soothing response from them,” she said.
Arm-chair psychologists believe this is because Indians have no concept of “personal space”. Real psychologists, while not dismissing the idea altogether, said the subject was more complicated than that.
Dr Pragya Rashmi, a consultant psychologist from the city, said the concept of “body buffer zone” in psychology the physical distance a person prefers to maintain from another varies between cultures.
“Physical proximity is a part of our culture. We easily touch other people through hugs and whatnot,” she said. Dr Rashmi noted that the idea of personal space differs even between those who live in urban spaces and those who live in rural, open spaces.
Clinical psychologist Aarthi Selvan, who runs a clinic in Begumpet, said the current behaviour of people at market yards and supermarkets can be explained in another way as well.
“During times like these, there is a component of fear and anxiety around the availability of resources. They aren’t sure if essential goods will be available,” she said. This nervousness could lead people to forget the risks of being in a crowd or not maintaining a distance from others. “There isn’t a lot of information being given to the general public. Their anxiety is understandable,” she said.
“In any case, the idea of social distancing is a privilege in our country. Most people can’t afford to live in a place where they have any real personal space,” she added.
Psychologists as well as many Dalit and Adivasi activists have noted that the term “social distancing” might not be the most ideal one to use in India.
Activists have noted that the term has caste undertones, and could allude to untouchability that was practised against certain communities in the country. Some have suggested it be replaced by “physical distancing”.
Dr Rashmi said, “The term ‘social distancing’ doesn’t clearly convey its purpose. People still don’t know why they should maintain a distance from others.” She suggested the use of “safe distance” instead.
Ms Selvan too said the word “social” was leading to the message being lost in transmission. “Indeed, ‘safe distance’ might work. It is less likely to elicit a threat response from people. It could also elicit a soothing response from them,” she said.
- How to Apply Onion Juice to Hair
- Patriotism is in thing, it’s Tricolour everywhere
- Celebs too wear fakes of reputed brands
- Elon Musk on fun trail says 'buying Coca Cola next'
- Restaurants, haleem bhattis see huge rush at sehri, iftar
- 'Keeping awake' habit high in Hyderabad
- Tinseltown's angel investors
- Amid survival anxieties, meditation as route to peace
- Stylish footsteps
- ‘Theatre has taught me a lot’
- An Indian at the Grammys
- Coffee goes skin-deep
- 'Wearable fitness trackers, step counters help overweight to shed pounds’
- An ode to maximalism
- High levels of stress, weight gain among people trying to cope with COVID situation
More Lifestyle News
Photos
Latest
- Kiara Advani, Sidharth Malhotra embrace parenthood for the second time
- ‘Sometimes we get addicted to our own greatness’: Manoj Bajpayee
- Dulquer Salmaan’s ‘Aakasamlo Oka Tara’ gets November 20 release date
- ‘Mirzapur: The Movie’ crosses Rs 100 crore at domestic box office in opening weekend
- Amitabh Bachchan admits difficulty decoding Gen Z slang
- Watch: Nagarjuna releases trailer of Allari Naresh-starrer ‘Ramba Oorvasi Menaka’
- “Tum bahut lambe ho…”: Big B shares struggles of early acting days
- Nayanthara reveals how Geethu Mohandas convinced her to join ‘Toxic’
- Sonu Nigam says childhood anger fuelled his passion and shaped his singing career
- Yash takes out extra time time to pose for selfies with fans before leaving Mumbai airport
Opinion Poll
Videos















