The idea of a homogeneous nation state is problematic: Hamid Ansari
Posted December 29th, 2014, 11:39 AM IST

New Delhi: Amid the raging row over conversions, Vice President Hamid Ansari on Sunday cautioned against connecting faith and history and propagating a "homogeneous" national identity, when there are over 4,600 communities in the country.
The Vice-President said the idea of a homogeneous nation is problematic.
"Our 4,635 communities, according to the Anthropological Survey of India, is a terse reminder about the care that needs to be taken while putting together the profile of a national identity," Mr Ansari said while inaugurating the 75th session of the Indian History Congress.
"The global scene in modern times has been replete with complexities and tensions of what has been called the national question. We live in a world of nation states but the idea of a homogeneous nation state is clearly problematic. Diversity is identifiable even in the most homogeneous of societies today," he said.
Warning against any strait-jacket edifice for national identity "that came to grief" in other societies, Mr Ansari said the pluralist structures in India that have stood the test for over six decades need "constant nurturing".
Mr Ansari highlighted the practical relevance of history and said it helps to learn from the mistakes of the past. He asserted that history also cannot be "faith-based".
"The domains of the two exist separately and conflation does not further the cause of either."
Mr Ansari said, "History helps us to know and learn from the mistakes of the past. Those mistakes relate to frailties in judgement leading to mistakes in statecraft and governance. These, as one historian has put it, could be due to tyranny or oppression, excessive ambition, incompetence or decadence, and folly or perversity."
The Vice-President said the idea of a homogeneous nation is problematic.
"Our 4,635 communities, according to the Anthropological Survey of India, is a terse reminder about the care that needs to be taken while putting together the profile of a national identity," Mr Ansari said while inaugurating the 75th session of the Indian History Congress.
"The global scene in modern times has been replete with complexities and tensions of what has been called the national question. We live in a world of nation states but the idea of a homogeneous nation state is clearly problematic. Diversity is identifiable even in the most homogeneous of societies today," he said.
Warning against any strait-jacket edifice for national identity "that came to grief" in other societies, Mr Ansari said the pluralist structures in India that have stood the test for over six decades need "constant nurturing".
Mr Ansari highlighted the practical relevance of history and said it helps to learn from the mistakes of the past. He asserted that history also cannot be "faith-based".
"The domains of the two exist separately and conflation does not further the cause of either."
Mr Ansari said, "History helps us to know and learn from the mistakes of the past. Those mistakes relate to frailties in judgement leading to mistakes in statecraft and governance. These, as one historian has put it, could be due to tyranny or oppression, excessive ambition, incompetence or decadence, and folly or perversity."
- Kiara Advani, Sidharth Malhotra embrace parenthood for the second time
- Amitabh Bachchan admits difficulty decoding Gen Z slang
- Yash takes out extra time time to pose for selfies with fans before leaving Mumbai airport
- Bollywood stars shower blessings on Anshula Kapoor Rohan Thakkar at wedding reception
- Shilpa Shirodkar recalls losing Chaiya Chaiya with SRK
- Watch Russian couple dramatic proposal atop Empire State Building sparks global buzz
- Aamir Khan says his wedding with partner Gauri Spratt will be intimate affair with family and friends
- Actress Sreeleela recalls balancing MBBS medical exams with Viral Vayyari song shoot on Doctors Day
- US removes four Indian firms from sanctions list
- Suriya joins hands with T J Gnanavel for new hombale films project
- US Iran agree to sustain Strait of Hormuz ceasefire resume broader nuclear talks
- Telangana Governor CM Revanth Reddy urge people to join fight against drug abuse
- Samantha Confirms Pregnancy Shares Maternity Leave Plans Have To Take A Small Break
- Allu Arjun to appear in court on Monday in Sandhya Theatre stampede case
- Yoga centres to be set up in all villages announces CM Chandrababu Naidu
More News
Photos
Latest
- Kiara Advani, Sidharth Malhotra embrace parenthood for the second time
- ‘Sometimes we get addicted to our own greatness’: Manoj Bajpayee
- Dulquer Salmaan’s ‘Aakasamlo Oka Tara’ gets November 20 release date
- ‘Mirzapur: The Movie’ crosses Rs 100 crore at domestic box office in opening weekend
- Amitabh Bachchan admits difficulty decoding Gen Z slang
- Watch: Nagarjuna releases trailer of Allari Naresh-starrer ‘Ramba Oorvasi Menaka’
- “Tum bahut lambe ho…”: Big B shares struggles of early acting days
- Nayanthara reveals how Geethu Mohandas convinced her to join ‘Toxic’
- Sonu Nigam says childhood anger fuelled his passion and shaped his singing career
- Yash takes out extra time time to pose for selfies with fans before leaving Mumbai airport
Opinion Poll
Videos















