Under US election law, Trump Jr.’s Russia emails may prompt probe
Posted July 12th, 2017, 10:41 AM IST

New York: Donald Trump Jr.'s meeting with a woman he was told was a Russian government lawyer who had incriminating information about Democratic candidate Hillary Clinton that could help his father's presidential campaign could lead investigators to probe whether he violated US election law, experts said.
Trump Jr. met the woman, lawyer Natalia Veselnitskaya, on June 9, 2016, after an email exchange with an intermediary.
The emails, tweeted by Trump Jr. on Tuesday, could provide material for Special Counsel Robert Mueller's probe into possible collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia during the 2016 presidential election.
In one of the emails dated June 3, 2016, Trump Jr. wrote: "If it's what you say I love it." He released the tweets after the New York Times said it planned to write about their contents and sought his comment.
Trump Jr. said in his tweets that nothing came of the meeting. Veselnitskaya told NBC News early on Tuesday she was not affiliated with the Russian government and had passed no information.
View image on Twitter
View image on Twitter
Follow
Donald Trump Jr. ? @DonaldJTrumpJr
Here is page 4 (which did not post due to space constraints).
8:31 PM - 11 Jul 2017
11,693 11,693 Retweets 18,473 18,473 likes
Twitter Ads info and privacy
"In retrospect, I probably would have done things a little differently," Trump Jr. said in an interview on Fox News. "For me, this was opposition research."
Collusion itself is not an actual crime under the US criminal code, so prosecutors would look to see if Trump Jr.'s conduct ran afoul of a specific law, legal experts said.
Moscow has denied interference in the US election, and President Donald Trump has said his campaign did not collude with Russia.
Alan Futerfas, Trump Jr.'s lawyer, did not respond to a request for comment. A spokesman for Mueller declined to comment.
One law that might come into play is the Federal Election Campaign Act, which makes it illegal for a foreign national to contribute to a US political campaign. The campaign is also prohibited from soliciting such contributions.
A contribution does not have to be monetary in nature, according to Paul S. Ryan, an attorney with watchdog group Common Cause. He said incriminating information about Clinton could be considered a contribution under the act.
Ryan said Trump Jr.'s "enthusiastic response" to the offer for information and particularly his proposal in his email to have a follow-up call the next week constituted "solicitation."
"That to me is an indication, a concession by Donald Trump Jr. that he wants and is requesting this information," Ryan said.
Joshua Douglas, a professor at the University of Kentucky College of Law, said Trump Jr.'s emails made it "more plausible" that there could be a criminal case against him.
James Gardner, an election law expert at the University of Buffalo Law School, said the election law was intended to target donations of cash or goods and services.
He said he did not believe Trump Jr. would have violated the law if he solicited damaging information about Clinton.
A federal law known as the general conspiracy statute that makes it illegal to conspire to commit a crime against or defraud the United States could also come into play if, for example, Donald Trump Jr. tried to help Russians hack into US computer networks. There was no indication that Trump Jr. did such a thing.
Andrew Wright, a professor at Savannah Law School who was associate counsel in the White House Counsel's Office under former Democratic President Barack Obama, said he thought Trump Jr.'s agreeing to meet with someone to discuss an illegal act would be enough to trigger a conspiracy charge.
"It's a very powerful tool," he said.
Trump Jr. met the woman, lawyer Natalia Veselnitskaya, on June 9, 2016, after an email exchange with an intermediary.
The emails, tweeted by Trump Jr. on Tuesday, could provide material for Special Counsel Robert Mueller's probe into possible collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia during the 2016 presidential election.
In one of the emails dated June 3, 2016, Trump Jr. wrote: "If it's what you say I love it." He released the tweets after the New York Times said it planned to write about their contents and sought his comment.
Trump Jr. said in his tweets that nothing came of the meeting. Veselnitskaya told NBC News early on Tuesday she was not affiliated with the Russian government and had passed no information.
View image on Twitter
View image on Twitter
Follow
Donald Trump Jr. ? @DonaldJTrumpJr
Here is page 4 (which did not post due to space constraints).
8:31 PM - 11 Jul 2017
11,693 11,693 Retweets 18,473 18,473 likes
Twitter Ads info and privacy
"In retrospect, I probably would have done things a little differently," Trump Jr. said in an interview on Fox News. "For me, this was opposition research."
Collusion itself is not an actual crime under the US criminal code, so prosecutors would look to see if Trump Jr.'s conduct ran afoul of a specific law, legal experts said.
Moscow has denied interference in the US election, and President Donald Trump has said his campaign did not collude with Russia.
Alan Futerfas, Trump Jr.'s lawyer, did not respond to a request for comment. A spokesman for Mueller declined to comment.
One law that might come into play is the Federal Election Campaign Act, which makes it illegal for a foreign national to contribute to a US political campaign. The campaign is also prohibited from soliciting such contributions.
A contribution does not have to be monetary in nature, according to Paul S. Ryan, an attorney with watchdog group Common Cause. He said incriminating information about Clinton could be considered a contribution under the act.
Ryan said Trump Jr.'s "enthusiastic response" to the offer for information and particularly his proposal in his email to have a follow-up call the next week constituted "solicitation."
"That to me is an indication, a concession by Donald Trump Jr. that he wants and is requesting this information," Ryan said.
Joshua Douglas, a professor at the University of Kentucky College of Law, said Trump Jr.'s emails made it "more plausible" that there could be a criminal case against him.
James Gardner, an election law expert at the University of Buffalo Law School, said the election law was intended to target donations of cash or goods and services.
He said he did not believe Trump Jr. would have violated the law if he solicited damaging information about Clinton.
A federal law known as the general conspiracy statute that makes it illegal to conspire to commit a crime against or defraud the United States could also come into play if, for example, Donald Trump Jr. tried to help Russians hack into US computer networks. There was no indication that Trump Jr. did such a thing.
Andrew Wright, a professor at Savannah Law School who was associate counsel in the White House Counsel's Office under former Democratic President Barack Obama, said he thought Trump Jr.'s agreeing to meet with someone to discuss an illegal act would be enough to trigger a conspiracy charge.
"It's a very powerful tool," he said.
- Kiara Advani, Sidharth Malhotra embrace parenthood for the second time
- Amitabh Bachchan admits difficulty decoding Gen Z slang
- Yash takes out extra time time to pose for selfies with fans before leaving Mumbai airport
- Bollywood stars shower blessings on Anshula Kapoor Rohan Thakkar at wedding reception
- Shilpa Shirodkar recalls losing Chaiya Chaiya with SRK
- Watch Russian couple dramatic proposal atop Empire State Building sparks global buzz
- Aamir Khan says his wedding with partner Gauri Spratt will be intimate affair with family and friends
- Actress Sreeleela recalls balancing MBBS medical exams with Viral Vayyari song shoot on Doctors Day
- US removes four Indian firms from sanctions list
- Suriya joins hands with T J Gnanavel for new hombale films project
- US Iran agree to sustain Strait of Hormuz ceasefire resume broader nuclear talks
- Telangana Governor CM Revanth Reddy urge people to join fight against drug abuse
- Samantha Confirms Pregnancy Shares Maternity Leave Plans Have To Take A Small Break
- Allu Arjun to appear in court on Monday in Sandhya Theatre stampede case
- Yoga centres to be set up in all villages announces CM Chandrababu Naidu
More News
Photos
Latest
- Kiara Advani, Sidharth Malhotra embrace parenthood for the second time
- ‘Sometimes we get addicted to our own greatness’: Manoj Bajpayee
- Dulquer Salmaan’s ‘Aakasamlo Oka Tara’ gets November 20 release date
- ‘Mirzapur: The Movie’ crosses Rs 100 crore at domestic box office in opening weekend
- Amitabh Bachchan admits difficulty decoding Gen Z slang
- Watch: Nagarjuna releases trailer of Allari Naresh-starrer ‘Ramba Oorvasi Menaka’
- “Tum bahut lambe ho…”: Big B shares struggles of early acting days
- Nayanthara reveals how Geethu Mohandas convinced her to join ‘Toxic’
- Sonu Nigam says childhood anger fuelled his passion and shaped his singing career
- Yash takes out extra time time to pose for selfies with fans before leaving Mumbai airport
Opinion Poll
Videos














